What Derivatives Really Are
A derivativeIn finance, a derivative is a contract between a buyer and a seller. The derivative can take various forms, depending on the transaction, but every derivative has the following four elements:an item that can or must be bought or sold, a future act which must occur, a price at which the future transaction must take place, and a future date by which the act must take place.Read on Wikipedia → is a financial contract whose value depends on something else, such as a currency, a share, or a commodity. Companies use these contracts to manage changing prices. Traders also use them to take risks and try to earn a profit.
The main difference between contracts is what each side agrees to do. A forward or a futures contract creates an obligation to buy or sell. An option gives its buyer a choice, in return for a fee.
Fixing the cost of a future payment
Suppose a US company imports equipment from Europe. It must pay its supplier €100,000 in three months. The company earns dollars, so it will need to buy euros to make that payment.
If one euro costs $1.10 when the payment is due, the equipment costs $110,000. If the rate rises to $1.20, it costs $120,000. The supplier still receives the same amount in euros, but the company needs more dollars.
The company can remove this uncertainty by agreeing on an exchange rate today. It makes a contract with a bank to buy €100,000 in three months at $1.10 per euro. This is a forward contractIn finance, a forward contract, or simply a forward, is a non-standardized contract between two parties to buy or sell an asset at a specified future time at a price agreed on in the contract, making it a type of derivative instrument. The party agreeing to buy the underlying asset in the future assumes a long position, and the party agreeing to sell the asset in the future assumes a short position. The price agreed upon is called the delivery price, which is equal to the forward price at the time the contract is entered into.Read on Wikipedia →. The future purchase price is fixed, and both sides must complete the deal.
The company agrees to buy euros, so it has a long positionIn finance, a long position in a financial instrument means the holder of the position owns a positive amount of the instrument. The holder of the position has the expectation that the financial instrument will increase in value. This is known as a bullish position. The term "long position" is often used in context of buying options contracts.Read on Wikipedia →. The bank agrees to sell euros, so it has a short positionIn finance, a position is the amount of a particular security, commodity or currency held or owned by a person or entity.Read on Wikipedia →. The date when they complete the exchange is the contract’s maturityIn finance, maturity or maturity date is the date on which the final payment is due on a loan or other financial instrument, such as a bond or term deposit, at which point the principal is due to be paid.Read on Wikipedia →.
The company will now pay $110,000 for its euros. If the market rate rises, the contract protects it from the extra cost. If the rate falls, the company must still use the agreed rate. It gives up the chance to buy euros more cheaply.
This use of a contract to reduce an existing risk is called hedgingA hedge is an investment position intended to offset potential losses or gains that may be incurred by a companion investment. A hedge can be constructed from many types of financial instruments, including stocks, exchange-traded funds, insurance, forward contracts, swaps, options, gambles, many types of over-the-counter and derivative products, and futures contracts.Read on Wikipedia →. The company wants a predictable bill, rather than a profit from currency trading.
The numbers here are examples, not bank quotes. We leave out fees, taxes, and interest costs. A real forward rate can differ from today’s exchange rate, partly because interest rates differ between currencies.
Private agreements and exchange trading
The company arranged its forward directly with a bank. This is part of the over-the-counter market, usually shortened to OTCOver-the-counter (OTC) or off-exchange trading or pink sheet trading is done directly between two parties, without the supervision of an exchange. It is contrasted with exchange trading, which occurs via exchanges. A stock exchange has the benefit of facilitating liquidity, providing transparency, and maintaining the current market price. In an OTC trade, the price is not necessarily publicly disclosed.Read on Wikipedia →. The two sides can agree on an amount and payment date that fit the company’s needs.
Banks often offer both a buying price and a selling price. These are the bid and ask. From the bank’s point of view, the bid is the price it pays to buy, and the ask is the price it charges to sell. The difference is the spreadThe bid–ask spread is the difference between the prices quoted for an immediate sale (ask) and an immediate purchase (bid) for stocks, futures contracts, options, or currency pairs in some auction scenario. The size of the bid–ask spread in a security is one measure of the liquidity of the market and of the size of the transaction cost. If the spread is 0 then it is a frictionless asset.Read on Wikipedia →, which adds to the customer’s trading cost.
A market makerA market maker is a firm or individual that provides liquidity by regularly quoting prices at which it is willing to buy an asset and sell it. It aims to earn the difference between those prices, known as the bid–ask spread, while managing the inventory and price risk created by its trades. By standing ready to trade on either side, market makers make it easier for other participants to buy or sell without waiting for a matching counterparty.Read on Wikipedia → provides these prices and is willing to take either side of a trade. This helps customers find someone to trade with.
An exchange works differently. It lists contracts with set sizes, dates, and settlement rules. Buyers and sellers submit orders, usually through an electronic system. They agree on the price, but do not design a new contract for every trade.
Standard terms make contracts easier to trade. They also mean a contract may not match a company’s exact payment amount or date.
Where a trade takes place is separate from how its obligations are handled. Some OTC deals remain between the original parties. Others go through a central clearing system, as exchange-traded contracts usually do.
How futures change the cash payments
A futures contractIn finance, a futures contract is a standardized legal contract to buy or sell something at a predetermined price for delivery at a specified time in the future, between parties not yet known to each other. The item transacted is usually a commodity or financial instrument. The predetermined price of the contract is known as the forward price or delivery price. The specified time in the future when delivery and payment occur is known as the delivery date. Because it derives its value from the value of the underlying asset, a futures contract is a derivative. Futures contracts are widely used for hedging price risk and for speculative trading in commodities, currencies, and financial instruments.Read on Wikipedia → also creates an obligation to buy or sell at an agreed price. It normally trades on an exchange, under the exchange’s standard terms.
A central counterparty, or CCPA central clearing counterparty (CCP), also referred to as a central counterparty, is a financial market infrastructure organization that takes on counterparty credit risk between parties to a transaction and provides clearing and settlement services for trades in foreign exchange, securities, options, and derivative contracts. CCPs are highly regulated institutions that specialize in managing counterparty credit risk. An extensive overview of the academic literature can be found in Berndsen (2021).Read on Wikipedia →, stands between the two sides. A clearing houseA clearing house, often written as clearinghouse, is a financial institution formed to facilitate the exchange of payments, securities, or derivatives transactions. The clearing house stands between two clearing firms.Read on Wikipedia → can perform this role: it becomes the buyer to the seller and the seller to the buyer. The risk that a party fails to pay is called counterparty riskCredit risk is the chance that a borrower does not repay a loan or fulfill a loan obligation. For lenders the risk includes late or lost interest and principal payment, leading to disrupted cash flows and increased collection costs. The loss may be complete or partial. In an efficient market, higher levels of credit risk will be associated with higher borrowing costs. Because of this, measures of borrowing costs such as yield spreads can be used to infer credit risk levels based on assessments by market participants.Read on Wikipedia →.
The CCP reduces this risk, but does not remove every risk from the trade. Traders still face losses when prices move against their positions.
A typical forward and a futures contract also differ in when the payments happen. Futures gains and losses are paid regularly, usually each trading day. Traders also post marginIn finance, margin is the collateral that a holder of a financial instrument has to deposit with a counterparty to cover some or all of the credit risk the holder poses for the counterparty. This risk can arise if the holder has done any of the following:Borrowed cash from the counterparty to buy financial instruments, Borrowed financial instruments to sell them short, Entered into a derivative contract.Read on Wikipedia →: money or other accepted assets held as security for their obligations.
Return to the importer. To keep the example simple, assume it can take a euro futures position covering exactly €100,000, at $1.10 per euro. This is a simplified position, not the specification of an actual exchange contract.
If the futures price falls to $1.09, the company’s long position loses $1,000:
€100,000 × ($1.09 − $1.10) = −$1,000
That loss must be paid even though the supplier’s bill is still months away. Meanwhile, a lower euro exchange rate makes the future equipment payment cheaper in dollars. The hedge can still serve its purpose, but the company needs cash to cover the futures loss now.
Margin is therefore neither the purchase price of a futures contract nor a limit on its losses. A trader may have to provide more money after opening the position.
Paying for the choice to buy
The importer may want protection against a stronger euro while keeping the benefit of a weaker euro. It can buy an optionIn finance, an option is a contract which conveys to its owner, the holder, the right, but not the obligation, to buy or sell a specific quantity of an underlying asset or instrument at a specified strike price on or before a specified date, depending on the style of the option.Read on Wikipedia → instead of fixing the rate with a forward.
A call optionIn finance, a call option is an option contract that gives its buyer the right, but not the obligation, to buy an agreed quantity of a particular commodity, security, or other financial instrument from the seller at a specified price. The asset or instrument to which the option relates is known as the underlying, and the specified purchase price is known as the strike price. The right may be exercisable at or before a specified date, depending on the terms of the option.Read on Wikipedia → gives its buyer the right to buy an asset at an agreed price. A put optionIn finance, a put or put option is a derivative instrument in financial markets that gives the holder the right to sell an asset, at a specified price, by a specified date to the writer of the put. The purchase of a put option is interpreted as a negative sentiment about the future value of the underlying stock. The term "put" comes from the fact that the owner has the right to "put up for sale" the stock or index.Read on Wikipedia → gives its buyer the right to sell. That agreed price is the strike priceIn finance, the strike price of an option is a fixed price at which the owner of the option can buy, or sell, the underlying security or commodity. The strike price may be set by reference to the spot price, which is the market price of the underlying security or commodity on the day an option is taken out. Alternatively, the strike price may be fixed at a discount or premium.Read on Wikipedia →. The buyer pays a fee called the premiumIn finance, an option is a contract which conveys to its owner, the holder, the right, but not the obligation, to buy or sell a specific quantity of an underlying asset or instrument at a specified strike price on or before a specified date, depending on the style of the option.Read on Wikipedia →.
Suppose the company pays $2,000 for a call that lets it buy €100,000 at $1.10 per euro in three months. The company can use this right, but does not have to.
If the market rate reaches $1.20, the company uses the option. It pays $110,000 for the euros, plus the $2,000 premium already paid. Its total cost is $112,000.
If the rate falls to $1.00, the company lets the option expire and buys euros at the market rate. Its total cost is $102,000, including the premium.
| Dollar cost of the €100,000 payment | Euro at $1.20 | Euro at $1.00 |
|---|---|---|
| Without a hedge | $120,000 | $100,000 |
| With the forward | $110,000 | $110,000 |
| With the call, including its premium | $112,000 | $102,000 |
The forward fixes the cost. The call sets a maximum cost under these assumptions, and the company still pays less if the euro falls.
The option’s payoffIn finance, an option is a contract which conveys to its owner, the holder, the right, but not the obligation, to buy or sell a specific quantity of an underlying asset or instrument at a specified strike price on or before a specified date, depending on the style of the option.Read on Wikipedia → is the value received from the right at expiry, before counting its purchase cost. At $1.20, the right to buy euros at $1.10 is worth $10,000. After subtracting the $2,000 premium, the profit on the option itself is $8,000.
The seller has a different position. It receives the premium but must meet the contract’s obligations if the buyer uses the right. The buyer can lose the full premium; the seller can lose much more than the premium received.
Options also differ in when they can be used. A European-style optionIn finance, the style or family of an option is the class into which the option falls, usually defined by the dates on which the option may be exercised. The vast majority of options are either European or American (style) options. These options—as well as others where the payoff is calculated similarly—are referred to as "vanilla options". Options where the payoff is calculated differently are categorized as "exotic options". Exotic options can pose challenging problems in valuation and hedging.Read on Wikipedia → can be exercised only at expiry. An American-style optionIn finance, the style or family of an option is the class into which the option falls, usually defined by the dates on which the option may be exercised. The vast majority of options are either European or American (style) options. These options—as well as others where the payoff is calculated similarly—are referred to as "vanilla options". Options where the payoff is calculated differently are categorized as "exotic options". Exotic options can pose challenging problems in valuation and hedging.Read on Wikipedia → allows earlier exercise during the period set by the contract. These names describe the rules, not where the option trades.
The purpose of the trade matters
The importer buys a derivative because it already has a euro payment to make. Another trader could buy the same contract without any bill to pay. That trader would be taking a currency risk to try to earn a profit. This is speculationIn finance, speculation is the purchase of an asset with the hope that that asset will become more valuable in a brief amount of time. The term can also refer to short sales, in which the speculator hopes to profit from a decline in the asset's value. Speculation often has a pejorative connotation, as the activity is linked to bubbles, economic downturns, and financial crises.Read on Wikipedia →.
Derivatives can give traders a large exposure for a relatively small initial payment. This is called leverageIn finance, leverage, also known as gearing, is any technique involving borrowing funds to buy an investment.Read on Wikipedia →. It can increase gains, but it also makes losses large compared with the money first committed. A futures loss can exceed the original margin. A purchased option can lose its entire premium.
ArbitrageArbitrage is the practice of taking advantage of a difference in prices in two or more markets – striking a combination of matching deals to capitalize on the difference, the profit being the difference between the market prices at which the unit is traded. Arbitrage has the effect of causing prices of the same or very similar assets in different markets to converge.Read on Wikipedia → has a different aim. A trader buys and sells equivalent assets or contracts at different prices to secure the difference. Both sides of the trade must be available, and the difference must cover trading and funding costs. Expecting two prices to move closer later is not enough to make a trade risk-free.
The same contract can therefore serve different purposes. Its terms determine the payments. The trader’s other assets and obligations determine which risks those payments reduce or add.
Where the Indian market fits
India’s modern exchange-traded share and index derivatives developed around 2000. BSEBombay Stock Exchange, is an Indian stock exchange based in Mumbai. Established in 1875, it is the oldest stock exchange in Asia, and also the tenth oldest in the world.Read on Wikipedia → launched index futures on 9 June 2000, followed by NSENational Stock Exchange of India Limited, also known as the National Stock Exchange (NSE), is an Indian stock exchange based in Mumbai. It is the 5th largest stock exchange in the world by total market capitalization, exceeding $5 trillion in May 2024.Read on Wikipedia → on 12 June. NSE added index options, options on individual shares, and futures on individual shares during 2001.
That was not the beginning of every Indian derivatives market. Commodity trading had an earlier history. The Reserve Bank of India also allowed certain financial institutions to use rupee interest-rate swaps and forward rate agreements in July 1999.
An interest-rate swapIn finance, an interest rate swap, IRS, is an interest rate derivative, IRD. It involves exchange of interest rates between two parties. In particular it is a "linear" IRD and one of the most liquid, benchmark products. It has associations with forward rate agreements (FRAs), and with zero coupon swaps (ZCSs).Read on Wikipedia → lets two sides exchange interest payments, often fixed-rate payments for payments based on a changing rate. It is another common type of derivative.
SEBIThe Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) is the regulatory agency for securities and commodity market in India under the administrative domain of Ministry of Finance within the Government of India. It was established on 12 April 1988 as an executive body and was given statutory powers on 30 January 1992 through the SEBI Act, 1992.Read on Wikipedia → regulates the exchange-traded share and commodity derivatives segments. RBIThe Reserve Bank of India (RBI) is the central bank of the Republic of India. It was established on 1 April 1935 by the British Raj, with enactment of the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934. Although, the RBI is owned by the Government of India, the RBI is an autonomous regulatory organisation for the Indian banking and financial system, exercising substantial amount of independence and power over the Indian economy. It is responsible for the issue, supply and control of the Indian rupee. It also manages the country's main payment systems and the foreign exchange under the FEMA Act, 1999.Read on Wikipedia → regulates relevant currency and interest-rate markets. CCILFinancial regulation in India is governed by a number of regulatory bodies. Financial regulation is a form of regulation or supervision, which subjects financial institutions to certain requirements, restrictions and guidelines, aiming to maintain the stability and integrity of the financial system. This may be handled by either a government or non-government organization. Financial regulation has also influenced the structure of banking sectors by increasing the variety of financial products available. Financial regulation forms one of three legal categories which constitutes the content of financial law, the other two being market practices and case law.Read on Wikipedia → provides central clearing for eligible rupee interest-rate contracts. Regulation and clearing are separate functions, performed by different institutions.
What can go wrong
A hedge can fail to match the amount, timing, or price risk of the original payment. A company can also struggle to fund margin payments before the benefit of its hedge arrives. If the supplier’s order is cancelled, a currency contract left open may create a risk the company no longer needs.
For this reason, companies need to track both the contract and the business payment it supports. They also need limits on position size and enough cash for possible losses and margin requirements.
A common mistake is to judge a hedge by the derivative’s result alone. If the euro falls to $1.00, the importer’s forward is $10,000 worse than buying euros at the market rate. But the purpose was to fix the equipment bill at $110,000. The company achieved that result.